01Classic
Baker’s choiceSmooth, rich, and timeless—our New York-style cheesecake features a creamy, dense filling with just the right touch of tang, nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust. Served with homemade strawberry purée on the side.
Sarah’s SweetsOrder nowHomemade · thoughtfully crafted
Homemade cheesecakes, baked locally.
Rich, handcrafted cheesecakes for celebrations, gatherings, or simply because you want something sweet.
6 inch · roughly 8 slices · $40 / 9 inch · roughly 12 slices · $60
The cheesecake shop
Choose your flavors
Add as many cheesecakes and flavors as you need, choose one pickup or delivery date, and pay for everything together.
01
02Chocolate
Fan favoriteA true chocolate lover’s dream. This rich cheesecake rests on a chocolate Oreo crust and is topped with homemade chocolate ganache—bringing chocolate flavor to every bite.
03Blueberry Crisp
Sweet, tart, and butteryA cozy blend of creamy cheesecake and fresh blueberries, topped with a golden crumble. It’s the perfect balance of smooth and crisp, sweet and tart.
04Strawberry Swirl
Bright strawberry ribbonLusciously creamy cheesecake swirled with homemade strawberry purée for the perfect touch of sweetness in every bite. A beautiful blend of flavor and color, baked into a graham cracker crust.
05Cookies + Cream
Creamy with a chocolate crunchA rich twist on classic cheesecake, baked over an Oreo crust and swirled with layers of crushed Oreos. Smooth, creamy, and comforting in every bite.
06Turtle
Chocolate, caramel, and pecanA decadent classic cheesecake drizzled with rich chocolate and homemade caramel, then topped with chopped pecans over a graham cracker crust.
Have a special idea?
Cheesecake is only the beginning.
Sarah can bake about anything you can imagine. Tell her what you have in mind, and she’ll work with you to make it happen.
Request any custom bake →Ready for dessert?
Build one sweet order.
Choose a flavor, size, and quantity, then add it to your order. Keep adding as many different cheesecakes as you want, choose pickup or free delivery, and select how you would like to pay.
Meet the baker
Hey there! I’m Sarah.
I’m Sarah Wardwell, the baker behind each cheesecake at Sarah’s Sweets. Through the support and hard work of my husband, Davis, I am honored to start baking homemade cheesecakes beyond friends and family.
Whether you’re celebrating someone, hosting, or simply craving something sweet, these cheesecakes are intentionally crafted to bring rich flavor to your table. Each cheesecake is a timeless dessert!
Warmly,
Sarah Wardwell
Sarah Wardwell
Pay your way
No added payment fees.
Everyone completes the same order form, then chooses Stripe, Venmo, Cash App, cash, or check.
Stripe
Build your full order and pay securely by credit or debit card with no added customer fee.
Build an order →Venmo
Complete the order form and select Venmo. Sarah will contact you to confirm the details and payment.
Build an order →Cash App
Complete the order form and select Cash App. Sarah will contact you to confirm the details and payment.
Build an order →Cash or check
Complete the order form and choose cash or check. Sarah will confirm the order and arrange payment.
Build an order →